No-knead dough (L) and The Dancer That Pizza Built Dough (R)

I’ll be brief.  I liked my dough better than the no-knead dough.  It colored up better in the oven, hence the flavor was better.  The textures were close, but mine had a more tender quality.

I think the reason that mine colored better in the oven – and let me say that I baked them identically at 450 degrees on a pre-heated stone – is that the dough contains just a touch of honey, 1 ounce.  The no-knead dough is a simple flour, yeast, salt, water formula.  I have a feeling that the 18-hour proofing time gives the yeast the opportunity to consume too many of the sugars in the flour, which results in a paler color when baked.  There simply aren’t enough sugars remaining for caramelization.  Would it have been possible to prevent it from over-proofing?  Sure.  I could have refrigerated it at some point to slow down the action of the yeast.  But that is not how the dough, so to speak, markets itself.  It is presented as one you can briefly stir up, cover, then forget about it.

As for the texture difference between them, my dough contains a bit of olive oil, as well as some cake flour, which is of a lower protein content than all-purpose flour.  Fats have a tenderizing effect on protein, and cake flour is of the lowest protein content available.

This was an interesting experiment.  I fell in love with my pizza dough all over again.

No-Knead Pizza (L), The Dancer That Pizza Built (R)


About thesolitarycook

I'm a chef, a cook, a teacher, a reader, a writer, a bike-rider, a dog- and cat-woman
This entry was posted in RECIPES. Bookmark the permalink.


  1. I also fell in love with your pizza dough. Very interesting comparison. I can really see the difference. I’ll stick to yours thank you! Not that Lahey’s dough isn’t good, I’m sure it is.

  2. Great experiment! I’ll stick with yours too 🙂

  3. Bevi says:

    Signed, sealed, delivered – I’m Yours!

  4. lapadia says:

    From the beginning I knew your pizza dough was “The” dough that would prevail, but thanks for the experiment 🙂 BTW – besides the dough I make (type depending on what kind of piza I am making) I have made yours twice and it has been added to my list of favorite pizza dough to make, it is a great “peel to stone” dough!!!

  5. ldpw says:

    The Saltine comment is perfect. Your pizza dough is juuust right, I think Goldilocks would agree also.

  6. panfusine says:

    That pizza just makes my head giddy!, I mean LOOK at it, its soo beautiful!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s